No Bake Cookies Recipe with Protein

This post may contain affiliate links. All opinions shared are my own. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Click to view our full disclosure.
All content is created by humans – not AI.

No time to eat or need a sweet treat at night? Try this healthy no bake cookies recipe or try the no bake brownies below!

I found a no bake cookies recipe online last week, and I really wanted to try it. After making one batch, I decided to play a little bit with the recipe. The final result was a really yummy, gooey cookie! They reminded me of cookie dough.

1/2 all natural peanut butter
1/2 cup unsweetened apple sauce
3 packets Stevia (original recipe called for 6, but it was too sweet for me)
1 scoop Vanilla Shakeology
1 cup dry oatmeal

Mix all ingredients well & form into golf ball size cookies. Freeze 1-2 hours & keep remaining cookies frozen. When you want one, just take it out of the freeze, thaw a little bit, and enjoy! It makes about 18 cookies and each is about 90 calories. Happy non-baking!

If you want a gooey cookie, eat them fresh. If you would like them to be a little more firm refrigerate for an hour and freeze the others.

What peanut butter do we use?

We really like American Dream’s Just Plain Nutty Peanut Butter because it’s so creamy and lower carb than your typical brands!

You can get 10% off using the code KIMANDKALEE.

Would you like to save this?

We'll email this post to you, so you can come back to it later!

Not a Vanilla Fan? Try the No Bake Chocolate Brownie

We made these yesterday. Here’s the verdict…
1. They are yummy.
2. No, they aren’t like a regular cake brownie, but they are really tasty =)
3. They are pretty gooey

They are a great choice if you are trying to pick a healthier option than processed cookies or candy. I’d definitely make them again.

No Bake Chocolate Brownie Recipe

½ cup natural smooth almond butter
1 scoop Chocolate Shakeology
1 medium banana, mashed
¼ cup quick-cooking rolled oats
3 Tbsp. chopped pecans

Combine all of the ingredients together, and then press the batter into a 1″ bowl. They need to be refrigerated for about an hour or longer to firm up. Each is about 100 calories.

*If you’ve never heard of or tried Shakeology, you can check out my review of it or email me at kalee@soreyfitness.com about it. We’ll figure out if it’s a good fit for you.

Do you like no bake cookies or brownie recipes?

4 Comments

WOW, these sound amazing. And we are always looking for recipes that are healthy and allergy free. We used to eat raw, but have backed away from that, but recall how wonderful it made me feel so I’ll have to check out shakeology! So glad to find you through the FB group!
xo ~kim (and chloe)