Caraway Rectangle Pan Review: Is Non-Toxic Bakeware Worth it?

This post may contain affiliate links. All opinions shared are my own. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Click to view our full disclosure.
All content is created by humans – not AI.

If you’ve been searching for non-toxic, high-quality bakeware like I have, you’ve probably seen Caraway. I decided to test their Rectangle Pan to see if it lives up to the hype and if it’s really worth the higher price tag.

Below I’ll share how it bakes, cleans, and holds up. I’ll also share if I’d buy it again given it’s more expensive than traditional cookware.

Table of Contents

Why I Chose Caraway’s Rectangle Pan

It was honestly time to replace my old 9×13 pan — the one that had started flaking black coating (yikes) — I went on the hunt for something non-toxic, durable, and worth the investment.

After loving our Caraway cookware set, I decided to try their Large Rectangle Pan.

Spoiler: I’m already planning to order the rest of the bakeware set.

Why I Wanted to Try the Caraway Rectangle Pan

I’m not a baker by nature, but I do love to bake, and my 9×13 pan is always my go-to for everything from casseroles to birthday cakes. I wanted a pan that could handle frequent use without leaching anything questionable into our food.

Caraway’s bakeware is made with:

An aluminized steel core for even heating
A ceramic non-stick coating that’s free of PTFE, PFOA, PFAS, lead, and cadmium
Stainless steel handles
A design that’s oven-safe up to 550°F
And, unlike most nonstick bakeware, Caraway’s is third-party tested for heavy metals and toxins.

Honestly, that peace of mind was worth the higher price point before I even baked anything.

Related: Why We Love Caraway’s Cookware Too

If you’re deciding whether to start with their cookware or bakeware, you might like our full Caraway Cookware Review.

My mom and I used Caraway’s cookware set for a while now, and it’s still one of our most-used kitchen upgrades.

My First Impressions

When I unboxed it, the first thing I noticed was how sturdy it felt.

It’s heavier than my old Wilton pan, but it’s not overly heavy. It just feels like a higher quality piece.

I chose the cream color to match our cookware set, and it looks beautiful sitting out on the counter.

I really do love that everything looks like it could be in a Nancy Meyers kitchen.

My Honest Caraway Rectangle Pan Review (a.k.a. How It Actually Performs)

I tested it by baking a white birthday cake. It’s one of my go-to recipes I’ve made dozens of times so it seemed like a safe place to start!

Here’s what I noticed:

I greased it lightly with butter and lined it with unbleached parchment paper, and it worked so well!
The cake baked evenly and rose beautifully.
The edges were lightly golden and smooth.
Cleanup was almost too easy — a quick wipe and it looked brand new.

I had to adjust my baking temperature and time slightly.
I normally bake at 375°F, but I lowered it to 350°F and reduced the bake time by about 3–4 minutes.

What I’ve Learned (and a Few Care Tips)

After a few uses, I’ve learned a few things worth sharing:

Don’t scoot the pan in and out of the oven — it can leave small scuffs on the bottom.
Let it cool before washing to protect the ceramic coating.
Hand-wash only — no dishwasher or metal utensils.
A small amount of butter or parchment paper helps the nonstick surface last longer. Avoid cooking sprays or oils, which can damage the coating over time.

These aren’t really a big deal for me, but worth knowing if you want your pan to stay pristine.

How It Compares to My Old Bakeware

Compared to my Wilton 9×13, the Caraway pan baked more evenly, cleaned up faster, and felt sturdier.

It also has no warping, no sticking, no weird smells like my original pan did. Don’t judge.

It’s also nice knowing I’m not cooking with a flaking nonstick coating.

That alone made it worth the switch.

The Cons

Let’s be honest — Caraway isn’t cheap. This is an investment piece.

You’ll want to treat it gently and hand-wash it, and yes, the handles get hot, so always use oven mitts!

But I’d rather have one great pan that lasts than five I need to replace every year.

Where to Buy Caraway Bakeware

You can shop Caraway directly on their official website, which usually offers the best color selection and bundle discounts.

You can also find select Caraway pieces at Target, Crate & Barrel, Amazon, Nordstrom, HomeGoods, and Costco — but inventory and colors vary.

If you’re planning to invest in more than one piece, I’d recommend getting the Caraway Bakeware Set

It includes the rectangle pan, muffin tin, loaf pan, and more — plus their clever storage organizer that saves serious cabinet space.

If that’s too pricey, you may like the 6-piece Caraway Bakeware set instead. It also has the rectangle pan in it.

Check out the Caraway Rectangle Pan or the full Caraway Bakeware Set

Would I Recommend the Caraway Rectangle Pan?

Absolutely. If you bake often and care about using non-toxic, high-quality cookware, the Caraway Rectangle Pan is worth every penny.

It bakes beautifully, looks stunning, and cleans up in seconds.

I’m already eyeing the muffin pan next . I’m dreaming about making cupcakes without the dreaded “stuck liner” issue.

Caraway Rectangle Pan FAQ

Is the Caraway rectangle pan dishwasher safe?

No. Caraway recommends handwashing with warm, soapy water and a non-abrasive sponge to preserve the ceramic coating.

Does food actually not stick to it?

Nothing has stuck so far even without cooking spray. I still use parchment paper though.

Can you use metal utensils with Caraway bakeware?

No. Stick to silicone, wood, or plastic utensils to avoid scratching the coating. You may like Caraway’s Utensil Set.

Is Caraway bakeware worth the price?

If you bake regularly and want something non-toxic, long-lasting, and beautiful, I think it’s absolutely worth it. It’s an investment, but one that pays off every time you use it.