Home / Nutrition / Shakeology vs Garden of Life’s RAW Meal: Which Should You Try in 2024?

Shakeology vs Garden of Life’s RAW Meal: Which Should You Try in 2024?

This post may contain affiliate links. All opinions shared are my own. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Click to view our full disclosure.
All content is created by humans – not AI.

If you’re comparing Garden of Life Raw Meal Replacement vs Shakeology, we’ll go over each option to try and help you decide which meal replacement shake is best for you. 

Shakeology vs Garden of Life's RAW Meal

Before we compare the two, both meal replacement powders offer more than typical protein shake. They are also both popular brands and similar products. Each nutritional shake contains 16+ grams of protein, superfoods, essential vitamins and minerals, and probiotics & digestive enzymes.

What is Shakeology?

Unlike Raw’s, Shakeology shakes offer two protein sources to pick from — whey protein and a vegan protein blend. The vegan protein powder consists of pea protein, oat protein, rice protein, chia seed, quinoa seed, flaxseed, and sacha inchi seed.

Shakeology is promoted as a nutrient dense shake that helps:

  • you feel better,
  • curb junk food cravings,
  • support healthy energy,
  • benefit overall health,
  • and support gut health.

We love it because it’s a healthy meal that is easy to prep first thing in the morning and a convenient way to get in some healthy fats and a good amount of protein.

Shakeology meal replacement drinks also come in a variety of flavors including chocolate, vanilla, tropical strawberry, cafe latte, greenberry, pumpkin spice, salted caramel, and peppemint mocha. We have a long list of Shakeology recipes to help you from getting bored too!

How is Shakeology sweetened?

Shakeology contains organic cane sugar and stevia to sweeten it, and xanthan gum to thicken it up.

Shakeology vs Garden of Life's RAW Meal

What is Garden of Life Raw Meal?

Garden of Life’s Raw Meal is an organic meal replacement designed to be a full meal for on-the-go people with active lifestyles.

Looking at the nutritional information side-by-side, RAW actually offers more protein and 5 fewer carbs than Shakeology. It also is fewer calories than Shakeology.

Garden of Life’s Raw Meal has no gluten, soy, dairy, tree nuts, filler ingredients, artificial colors, flavors, sweeteners, or preservatives. It also won’t cost you as much money as Shakeology.

The Downside

This high protein shake is a convenient option for someone following a vegan diet, but it’s only available in chocolate and vanilla. The texture of this drink isn’t smooth either. It can be a bit grainy and sometimes hard to get smooth. It’s not a rich and creamy texture at all. 

How is Garden of Life Raw Meal sweetened?

It is sweetened with erythirtol and stevia.

protein shake comparison

Shakeology vs life’s raw meal Comparison:

  Garden of Life’s RAW Meal Shakeology (vegan)
Calories 130 160
Grams of Fat 2.5 3
Grams of Protein 20 16
Grams of Carbs 13 18
Grams of Sugar 1 7
Grams of Fiber 3 6
Digestive Enzymes Yes Yes
Variety fo Flavors No (2 Flavors) Yes (6 + Seasonal)
Whey Option No Yes

It should also be noted that the whey protein version of Shakeology is lower in calories and carbs than the plant-based version.

Try Garden of Life in chocolate and vanilla or SHAKEOLOGY

Now that you know that they’re both similar in how they’re meal replacements and healthier options than scarfing down junk food or processed food, let’s talk about some of the pros and cons to be aware of. 

Final thoughts on Shakeology vs Garden of Life’s RAW Meal

While there are 100s of different shakes and popular weight loss supplements on the market, both of these meal replacement products offer good stuff in them!

The best way to see better results in your weight loss is to commit to a healthy diet and workout program like Beachbody’s 21 Day Fix. If you’re considering exercising, you may want to look at a Beachbody Challenge Pack which includes Beachbody on Demand (streaming workouts) and Shakeology into one bundled price.

Which one is best for me?

To decide which one works best for you, it’s a good idea to read the nutrients and try and decide what you’re trying to accomplish. If fueling your body with organic nutrients and foods are important, Life’s Raw Meal is going to be the best choice when comparing the two. 

But if you’re looking for a meal replacement shake that has the consistency of a milkshake while still being low in calories and fat, Shakeology will deliver that time and time again. 

shakeology vs garden of life protein comparison

To Summarize:

Both brands are great meal replacement shakes and could be enjoyed in moderation because you can have too many protein shakes in a day.

We recommend looking over each brand’s ingredient list and nutritional values as you search for your perfect fit. 

Also, if you’re on a keto diet, you will need to add fat to either of these shakes. We like to use MCT Oil.

You’d also want to ask your doctor or a medical professional if you’re looking for a supplement to help with your gut health or blood sugar.

Try Garden of Life in chocolate and vanilla or SHAKEOLOGY

More Shakeology Recipes To Try

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.